How AI-Powered Cahoot Returns Management Reduces Ecommerce Fraud

Verified and Reviewed

Last updated on June 23, 2025

In this article

9 minutes

Join 26,741 eCommerce Leaders Today

Fraudulent returns and refund abuse are eating into ecommerce profits like termites in a timber shack. We’re not just talking about a few bad actors. This is a systemic issue. Every time someone pulls a fast one, returning a used dress, faking a receipt, or claiming a package never arrived, ecommerce businesses bleed money. But here’s the good news: AI is finally catching up.

Businesses that implement AI-powered fraud detection tools gain a competitive advantage in the ecommerce space, reducing losses and improving operational efficiency.

This article explores how AI-powered returns management is giving merchants the upper hand, using machine learning and advanced fraud detection tools to sniff out shady behavior while keeping the experience smooth for legitimate customers. The tech is here, it’s learning fast, and it’s reshaping how we handle ecommerce returns.

The Real Cost of Returns Fraud

Returns fraud isn’t just annoying, it’s financially devastating. Think about:

  • Wardrobing: Wear once, return as “new”.
  • Switch fraud: Return a knockoff and keep the real thing.
  • Empty box scams: Return a box with no item inside, claim it’s there.
  • Refund fraud: Claim the item never arrived, even when it did.

Customers exploit return policies by making false claims about product defects or delivery issues, manipulating the system for personal gain. Fraudulent return activities also include stolen merchandise returns and targeting high-value items such as luxury goods.

All of these fall under fraudulent returns and refund fraud, and they’re on the rise. According to the National Retail Federation, ecommerce losses from return abuse now top tens of billions of dollars annually.

AI analyzes return data and return patterns to identify patterns and fraud patterns in return transactions, helping businesses detect and prevent evolving forms of return fraud.

The old methods, manual checks, strict return policies, and restocking fees, aren’t cutting it anymore. They hurt genuine customers and barely scratch the surface of sophisticated scams. That’s where AI fraud detection for ecommerce returns steps in.

How AI Detects Fraud in the Returns Process

AI-powered returns management combines machine learning algorithms, transaction data, returns data, and customer behavior to spot bad actors before they strike. AI-powered systems are designed to prevent fraud throughout the returns process. Here’s how:

1. Photo Verification & Image Recognition

AI can evaluate customer-submitted images of returned items to:

  • Detect box fraud or item switching.
  • Compare the product’s appearance to a verified new version.
  • Identify wear, missing parts, or damage that contradicts the return reason.

This allows brands to detect fraudulent activity before it’s even shipped back.

2. Pattern & Anomaly Detection

Machine learning excels at spotting unusual patterns in behavior:

  • Return frequency: Has the customer returned too many high-value items?
  • Geolocation: Is the return request coming from a region known for return scams?
  • Purchase timing: Did they buy during a sale and return right after peak season?

These patterns raise fraud risks and trigger review or denial workflows.

3. Cross-Platform and Channel Monitoring

AI systems can check across multiple returns and ecommerce channels, identifying if a return was initiated:

  • For the same item on multiple platforms.
  • Using fake receipts.
  • From a buyer who already claimed store credit somewhere else.

AI can also monitor for account takeover attempts by detecting unusual account activities, such as frequent address changes, excessive returns, or high-value purchases. When suspicious account activity is detected, AI can recommend enabling multi-factor authentication to add an extra layer of security and prevent unauthorized access.

This multi-touch intelligence is a game-changer for fraud prevention goals.

4. NLP for Reason Analysis

Natural language processing (NLP) can analyze written return reasons and flag:

  • Repeated use of vague claims like “defective”.
  • Scripted language that suggests fraud rings.

It’s subtle, but over time, it sharpens fraud detection and helps businesses adapt.

5. Smart Risk Scoring

With returns management systems like Cahoot, each return is assigned a fraud risk score based on:

  • Customer history
  • Returns data
  • Known red flags like frequent returns, high-value items, high-risk transactions, or mismatched shipping info

High-risk returns may trigger:

  • Photo verification
  • Manual review
  • Limited refunds (e.g., store credit only)

How Cahoot Uses AI to Catch Return Fraud Before It Hits Your Warehouse

Here’s the short version: Cahoot’s AI-powered returns system sniffs out sketchy returns before they even hit your dock. No detective hats or magnifying glasses required. It’s proactive fraud prevention baked right into the returns process, built for ecommerce teams who don’t have time (or money) to waste on refund fraud and box scams.

Here’s how it plays out in real life: a customer clicks “return,” and instead of handing them a prepaid label like candy at a parade, Cahoot asks for photos. Item, packaging, maybe even the serial number. That’s when the AI kicks in, checking everything against the original order. Does the item match what was sold? Is the box suspiciously light? Are they trying to return a broken knockoff instead of the actual product? The system flags anything that smells off. No human has to squint at a blurry JPEG; AI’s doing the heavy lifting.

And if things look really fishy? Cahoot assigns a fraud risk score based on the customer’s history, return frequency, location, and transaction data. Say this person’s been sending back a lot of high-value items or triggering patterns tied to refund fraud, Cahoot might put the brakes on the refund, sending it to manual review or straight-up denying it. It’s like having a savvy fraud analyst on call, 24/7, who doesn’t need coffee breaks.

But that’s not all, it gets sharper with every return. The system learns what fraud looks like. Maybe it flags addresses linked to repeat offenders. Maybe it notices “this person always returns luxury goods two days before the return window closes.” The more it sees, the smarter it gets. Over time, it recommends policy tweaks that actually make sense, like tightening windows for excessive returns or requiring restocking fees on high-risk items.

Cahoot also checks serial numbers in real time. That means box fraud, where someone swaps the product and sends back a decoy, gets stopped cold. If the serial number doesn’t match what was sold? Game over. No refund. No restock. Just one more fake return that never made it through the door.

All of this happens quietly in the background, streamlining the returns process for good customers while catching the bad ones red-handed. That’s the beauty of machine learning in ecommerce returns: it doesn’t just react, it predicts. And when refund fraud can bleed your margins dry faster than a flash sale, that kind of protection isn’t just nice to have, it’s essential.

Cahoot’s AI isn’t trying to micromanage your returns team; it’s giving them superpowers. So your operations run leaner, your legit customers stay happy, and your profits stay where they belong. In your pocket.

How AI Preserves Customer Trust

One of the trickiest parts of returns fraud is not alienating loyal customers. Efficient returns processes powered by AI improve customer satisfaction by reducing friction and delays. A good AI doesn’t just block fraud, it enables a positive customer experience by:

  • Fast-tracking legitimate customers
  • Preventing false positives through layered detection
  • Using customer verification sparingly and intelligently

In short, it finds the right balance between fraud prevention and a frictionless returns process.

Behind the Scenes: What AI Actually Looks At

This isn’t black magic, it’s smart automation trained on mountains of data:

  • Historical data: Past behaviors of repeat offenders and loyal shoppers
  • Data points: Shipping speed, order value, return time frame
  • Customer data: Addresses, accounts, payment histories
  • Delivery tracking: GPS drops vs. “item not received” claims

Together, these inputs help detect fraud across a spectrum, from empty box fraud to money laundering via returns.

The Business Benefits

When ecommerce companies implement AI-powered returns management, they see results fast. These benefits contribute to the long-term success of ecommerce businesses:

✔ Reduced Operational Costs

  • Less need for manual review
  • Faster returns management process

✔ Improved Customer Loyalty

  • Quicker refunds for genuine customers
  • Confidence that return policies are fair

✔ Higher Margins

  • Fewer fraudulent returns and chargebacks
  • More high-value items are resold instead of being written off

✔ Smarter Policy Decisions

  • AI insights guide better rules
  • Target return abuse without punishing everyone

It’s a full-circle win for ecommerce businesses who want to scale securely.

Final Thoughts: AI Is the Future of Fraud Prevention

Return fraud is constantly evolving. So are the tools to fight it. By leveraging AI and machine learning in the returns management space, sellers are turning what used to be a liability into a competitive edge.

With platforms like Cahoot, advanced technology no longer belongs only to the big guys. Even mid-size online stores can now fight receipt fraud, friendly fraud, and return scams with precision.

So next time someone tries to game the system with a personal gain hustle, just remember: AI sees all. And it doesn’t blink.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does AI detect fraudulent returns in ecommerce?

AI fraud detection for ecommerce returns works by analyzing returns data, customer behavior, and product images to identify suspicious patterns. It can flag issues like empty box fraud, receipt fraud, or mismatched serial numbers by comparing return requests against historical transaction data and trained machine learning algorithms.

What is the difference between return abuse and friendly fraud?

Return abuse often involves intentional schemes like wardrobing or box switching for personal gain, while friendly fraud includes tactics like claiming an item was never received to get a refund. Both forms of fraudulent activity are increasing in ecommerce returns, and AI-powered systems help detect these behaviors quickly.

Can AI-powered returns management improve customer satisfaction?

Yes. By separating legitimate customers from bad actors, AI-powered returns management allows genuine customers to experience faster processing, easier refunds, and less hassle, while fraudsters face more scrutiny. This helps maintain customer loyalty, customer trust, and a positive customer experience.

What types of ecommerce return fraud does AI help prevent?

AI helps identify and prevent a range of fraud types, including stolen merchandise returns, false claims, empty box fraud, refund fraud, and return scams. It uses data points like return frequency, image analysis, and customer history to flag high-risk transactions for further review.

Why is AI better than traditional fraud prevention methods?

Unlike manual reviews or blanket return policies that can frustrate loyal customers, AI fraud detection tools use advanced technology to spot fraud patterns in real-time. This results in lower operational costs, stronger fraud defenses, and better long-term success for ecommerce businesses.

Written By:

Indy Pereira

Indy Pereira

Indy Pereira helps ecommerce brands optimize their shipping and fulfillment with Cahoot’s technology. With a background in both sales and people operations, she bridges customer needs with strategic solutions that drive growth. Indy works closely with merchants every day and brings real-world insight into what makes logistics efficient and scalable.

Cahoot P2P Returns Logo

Turn Returns Into New Revenue

Convert returns into second-chance sales and new customers, right from your store